Why Christian Marriages Fail

Tomi Toluhi

Marriage was designed by God to be a lasting, fulfilling union between two individuals totally committed to Him and to each other. God loves marriage, He created it and He celebrates it at every opportunity in scripture. One of the most profound scriptures about marriage, in my view, is Ephesians 5:31-32. Paul the Apostle, quoting Genesis 2:24, makes an astonishing assertion. ‘As the Scriptures say, “A man leaves his father and mother and is joined to his wife, and the two are united into one.” This is a great mystery, but it is an illustration of the way Christ and the church are one’. This absolutely blows my mind! The relationship between Christ and the Church is the culmination of God’s Masterplan for man; it is God’s finest work hatched in Genesis and revealed in Jesus. To think that God would see fit to use something as human as a marriage between a man and a woman to illustrate such a majestic divine concept amazes me.

An illustration is an example that clarifies or makes a concept easier to understand. Every time a Christian man and woman stand at the altar and say ‘I do’ , instantly they are supposed to become a walking message system, a giant reflection of how Christ loves us and how we respond to Him in love. Our marriages are supposed to make it is easier for a dying world to comprehend the profound love of Christ reflected in His sacrifice for the Church and our heartfelt response to Him. I find myself asking, ‘What am I reflecting? Am I accurately reflecting the selfless, patient, unconditional love of Christ in my marriage?’ That’s a question every Christian husband and wife should consider every now and then. ‘When the world looks at my marriage, what impression do they get about Christ and His Church?’ Many times, in the midst of the ordinariness of living with one’s spouse day in day out; in the midst of raising kids, paying bills and juggling various life responsibilities, we forget just how spiritual marriage is in God’s eyes.

It really touches my heart when I speak to Christian couples who are struggling in their marriages. The Church seems to have become less and less immune to the same marital struggles faced by couples who profess no faith at all. This troubles me. Should it not be a given that if we serve the God who dreamed up the idea of marriage in the first place, we should be able to understand His formula for making it work? Should Christian marriages not be successful by default? If only it were that simple. It has become apparent to me that a Christian marriage is not necessarily one where both parties profess Christianity and say their vows before a priest or pastor. A Christian marriage is one where both parties are committed to practising God’s principles for marriage, and that’s where the rubber meets the road. In some Christian marriages there seems to be a wide disconnect, a chasm between what we know and what we do. We know all the right scriptures and can quote them at the drop of a hat but we are often totally unprepared to live them out when the going gets tough. It seems we want to get the results God promised without doing what God commanded.

Jesus made it quite clear in Matthew 7:24-26 that the marriages that survive the inevitable storms of life are those where the parties involved are prepared not only to hear what He has to say but more importantly to do it. The disconnect has always been in the doing. It is of no consequence what we know if we are unprepared to do it. So why is doing so difficult for us? Why do we love to trumpet what God says our spouse should do and skip over what God says we should be doing? In a spirited exchange between Jesus and the Pharisees in Matthew 19:3-8, He exposed the reason why doing can be so hard.

Pharisees: Is it ever lawful for a man to divorce his wife?

Jesus: Haven’t you read that in the beginning God created humanity male and female? Don’t you remember what the story of our creation tells us about marriage? “For this reason, a man will leave his mother and father and cleave to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.” If a husband and wife are one flesh, how can they divorce? Divorce would be a bloody amputation, would it not? “What God has brought together, let no man separate.”

Pharisees: Why did Moses explain that if a man leaves his wife, then he must give her a certificate of divorce and send her away, free and clear of him?

Jesus: Moses permitted you to divorce your wives because your hearts were hard. But divorce was an innovation, an accommodation to a fallen world. There was no divorce at creation.

This exchange says it all. Divorce was never in God’s original plan for man. When couples divorce, they advance all sorts of reasons why their marriage is no longer tenable – irreconcilable differences, money problems, sexual problems, abuse, neglect, in-law interference; the list goes on and on. However, when all is said and done, divorce boils down to one thing – hardness of heart of either one or both parties. Hardness of heart is a condition which Christians sometimes unknowingly develop. When our hearts become cold, insensitive, unfeeling, and unyielding to God’s word and the promptings of the Holy Spirit, we run our marriages on the basis of our fallen human nature and the inevitable result is disaster. It is not storms that destroy marriages, it is our unwillingness to yield to what God wants us to do in the midst of the storm because it is inconvenient, requires humility, demands sacrifice or is downright difficult, that inevitably leads to the unravelling of a Christian marriage.

Marriage is not easy; it has never been. Anyone who tells you otherwise is being plain dishonest. Regardless of how wonderful you and your spouse are, marriage requires an ongoing willingness to sacrifice for the benefit of the other person, even when it is inconvenient. Often it means taking your eyes off your own legitimate needs to shine the spotlight on the needs of your spouse and meet them. Sometimes, it demands uncommon humility when you have to serve your spouse like Christ served His disciples and washed their feet. Time and again it requires a heartfelt devotion that makes you see the good in your spouse even when they and the world want to focus on their shortcomings. Always, it requires a forgiving heart to overlook the inevitable faults of your spouse and still respect and celebrate them wholeheartedly. All of this requires a sensitive, generous heart which can only come from hearing and following the promptings of God. What is God asking you to do in your marriage today? Whatever it is, do not harden your heart. The rewards of a true Christian marriage are well worth the investment.

By Tomi Toluhi May 17, 2025
Understanding Money Agendas is probably one of the most important insights that will equip you to build financial compatibility in your marriage. Each one of us approaches relationships and enters into marriage with a money agenda and you need to explore and understand your spouse's money agenda and harmonise it with yours to minimise conflict.
By Tomi Toluhi May 17, 2025
Welcome to the world of the Expressive where money means acceptance. Respect and acceptance are the focus of the Expressive's financial agenda. Money is seen as a means to express one’s uniqueness and earn the admiration of others.
By Tomi Toluhi May 17, 2025
Welcome to the world of the Expressive where money means acceptance. Respect and acceptance are the focus of the Expressive's financial agenda. Money is seen as a means to express one’s uniqueness and earn the admiration of others.
Couple getting married in sunset
By Tomi Toluhi March 22, 2025
The decision of who to marry is potentially one of the most important decisions you will ever make in your life. Who you marry will significantly impact upon the outcome of your life - who you become, what you can accomplish and how fulfilling your life will be. Here are six crucial questions that you should ask before and after you say "I do."
Tomi Toluhi on the Analytic Money Personality
By Tomi Toluhi March 22, 2025
Welcome to the world of the Analytic where money means security. Saving and planning for the future are the focus of the Analytic’s financial agenda. Money is seen as a means to protect them and their loved ones from life’s difficulties and prepare for the future.
Currency from different countries
By Tomi Toluhi March 22, 2025
Welcome to the world of the Amiable where money means love. Relationships and people are the focus of the Amiable’s financial agenda. Money is seen as a means of expressing love and affection to others.
Tomi Toluhi on how your money language shapes your marriage
By Tomi Toluhi March 22, 2025
Join Tomi Toluhi for the replay of an engaging live Zoom event designed to help couples navigate money language differences in marriage. During this session, you'll learn how to improve financial communication, and build a stronger, more united approach to managing finances together.
By Tomi Toluhi March 22, 2025
Join Tomi and Martins Toluhi for the replay of an engaging live Zoom event designed to help couples navigate the often-challenging topic of money in marriage. During this session, you'll learn how to improve financial communication, and build a stronger, more united approach to managing finances together.
Tomi Toluhi on money ideas for marriage
By Tomi Toluhi March 22, 2025
Do you ever feel like money has created a barrier between you and your spouse? Maybe arguments flare up over budgeting—one of you saves while the other spends—or you feel nervous to even suggest spending. It’s as if you both see money completely differently, and before you know it, finances are creating conflict instead of connection. The truth is, money can be one of the most challenging aspects of any relationship. But understanding the unique way you and your spouse view money can drastically improve the strength of your connection and sense of harmony in marriage. Here are three things that could transform your marriage and help you build greater financial intimacy.
A man is carrying a woman on his back and they are laughing.
By Tomi Toluhi December 18, 2024
Sharon was a God-loving, go-getting, hard-driving, ambitious woman with grand dreams of conquering the world. She had all her plans carefully laid out. She would own her own business by 35, hit her first million by 37, exponentially grow her business and by 40 she would branch out into real estate acquisition. Her ultimate goal was to make millions, not for herself, but to provide a better life for orphaned children in her community. She had felt the pain of being parent-less and passed from relative to relative with no real stability growing up. She knew what it felt like to go to bed hungry and cold. No child should ever have to go through what she went through growing up. She was determined to do everything in her power to rescue, nurture and care for as many orphans as she could. Mark was a stable, godly, focused man with the ministry on his mind. For as long as he could remember, he had always felt a divine call to be a missionary. Reaching unreached people-groups was his consuming passion. He knew without a shadow of a doubt that he wanted to spend his life preaching, teaching and pastoring in an island community where no Christian church existed. He was committed to living among these forgotten people and reflecting the light and love of Jesus to them. Then Mark met Sharon. They fell in love, had a whirlwind courtship, got married…and reality struck. You can already tell where their story is heading. Wondering what became of Mark and Sharon? We will never find out because they are entirely fictional but their story illustrates a point which I have observed graphically playing out in some marriages. It is entirely possible to fall in love with someone who shares your Christian values but whose life values are wildly different from yours. Your values manifest in two different ways; what is right and what is wrong in your view, and what matters to you most. The dictionary supports this distinction in our understanding of values. Values could refer to the principles or standards of behaviour which you subscribe to, including your commitment to live by Biblical standards, but on the other hand values could equally refer to your judgement of what is important in life. Sometimes Christian singles are encouraged to pursue a relationship with someone because they are both Christians and want to please God with their lives, ignoring the fact that pleasing God means different things to different people. Your desire to please God will play out differently in your life compared to the person who sits next to you in Church on Sunday, based on your values. Your assignment is to find someone whose life values align closely to yours so that you can both stay true to your values in marriage. To some people, pleasing God simply means living a quiet life raising their families in a godly manner. Others want to go out in the marketplace, business, politics or academia and make a big difference as leaders. Yet others want to dedicate their lives fully to God’s work in some form of ministry, caring spiritually for a lost and dying world. None of these approaches is more noble than the next; they’re just different. What is right for one person may not be right for the other. It’s all a question of what matters to you and how God wired you internally. Amos 3:3 makes a succinct statement in this regard. “Do two people walk hand in hand if they aren’t going to the same place?” In other words, before you hitch your wagon to someone else’s vehicle, ask yourself “Are we heading in the same direction?” If someone is heading for Australia and the other person is heading for Austria, the destinations sound similar but the direction of travel for those two countries is completely different. The destination you intend to arrive will determine the route you choose to travel in life. If you get in the same vehicle with someone going in a different direction, one of three things will happen; you will arrive at your desired destination and they won’t, they will arrive at their desired destination and you won’t, or neither of you will arrive at your preferred destination. When people fall in love and emotions are running high, it’s easy to think that these things don’t matter, or that they will sort themselves out with time. Twenty years of counselling married couples suggests otherwise to me. When the music stops and the stars fall out of their eyes, reality collides with fantasy as they slowly come to terms with the fact that one or both of them will need to compromise on their values for the survival of their marriage, and compromise you must. If you are already married to someone whose values are diametrically opposed to yours, compromise is your only option because in God’s eyes the survival of your marriage has to take precedence over your closely held dreams. When I think about my life and the things that drive me daily, I realise how blessed I am to be married to a man who is driven by a similar impetus. He encourages me to fulfil God’s call for my life because it aligns with God’s call on His life. Our values are congruent. I shudder to think what my life would have been like if I had married a man who dances to the beat of a different drum. I would have had to lay aside all the possibilities before me to embrace a different future. It would have been a painful but inescapable compromise. Values are critical because they influence how you choose to spend your energy, where you invest your time and how you allocate your money. Consequently, if your values are fundamentally different from your spouse’s, you may love each other but you will not be able to enjoy living with each other until you have made deep and necessary compromises. There will be many fault-lines and potential battlegrounds where you will disagree and there will be no ‘right’ answer. If you want different things in life but you want to be in each other’s lives, something will have to give. You will either have to be faithful to your love or faithful to your values; the best marriages occur when you can be both at the same time.  If you’re considering getting married to someone, spend time exploring with them what their values are. Ask questions and read between the lines of every conversation, trying to sense what matters to them. Crucially, observe their lifestyle. A person’s values are more eloquently conveyed by the life they live than the words they speak. When you observe the trajectory of someone’s life, where they will land is predictable. An oak tree doesn’t become one overnight, but the leaves of the tiny seedling will tell you what it’s future holds. Ask…listen…observe, and above all else be prayerful.
More Posts